Weekly Press Review – 3 July 2015

The Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries (DAFF) has made headlines again this week with commercial abalone quota holders hitting out at the department’s new draft policies for long-term quota allocations.

Abalone SA described the new draft policy as “a superficial copy and paste job”, leaving quota holders with no choice, but to “reject the entire process”.

More criticism was launched regarding the public meetings held around the coast to discuss key concerns.  Each meeting was scheduled to be only two hours in length, with all 11 sectors represented at each meeting, making it impossible for concerned quota holders to have their say.  Most meetings were scheduled after the deadline for public comment anyway, making them effectively null and void.

As of yet, department spokesperson Carol Moses has offered no comment.

There has been surprising reactions in the press to complaints by members of Fresh Air for Hout Bay and other Hout Bay residents regarding the smell of fish emanating from the Oceana fish factory in the area.

Roscoe Jacobs, also a resident of Hout Bay, and a member of the Hout Bay Civic Association, has been quoted in the press as saying that the “unbearable smell” from the factory, also represents the smell of money.  The factory employs 226 workers, most of whom come from the Hout Bay area.   Without the factory, those individuals would not be able to make a living and put food on the table for their families.  He feels that those doing the complaining were well aware of the factory when they moved into the area.

It would seem that there are always two sides to every story and that the inconvenience of a bad smell surely does not compare to losing the chance to earn a living and provide for your family.


5 thoughts on “Weekly Press Review – 3 July 2015

  1. The numbers in this article are grossly incorrect. According to the Lucky Star Fishmeal factory only 102 people are permanently employed at the factory. S percentage of those are from Hout Bay. There are roughly 80000 inhabitants in Hout bay suffering from a rotten chemical stench emanating from the factory. Roscoe is a radical ANC member known to be on the payroll of Oceana. There are indeed more than one side to a story. This factory is holding back the community, especially Hangberg with thousands of unemployed residents… Best to research better before writing an article


    • Hi Edward – this is just a round up of what was reported in the media about the maritime industry over the last week in Cape Town and not an original article. As such we only report what the media is saying. The magazine is likely to pick up the story further.


      • Thanks for the update. It was just interesting to me that some very incorrect data was picked up – especially when we just had 3 articles in local media (die Burger, cape Argus and cape times) telling a much more accurate story. As I recently read on Fresh Air for Hout Bay: “One has to wonder: Do Oceana CEO Francois Kuttel’s kids clothes also stink of rotten fish and chemicals when they go to their posh Constantia schools…?” 😉
        Thanks again for clarifying.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s